Blog

The February 9, 1971 Sylmar earthquake and what it taught the city

A magnitude 6.6 dawn quake in the San Gabriel foothills toppled hospitals and freeways, nearly broke a dam, and rewrote California's building and fault rules.

It was 6:00 a.m. on Tuesday, February 9, 1971, still dark over the north end of the San Fernando Valley, and the ground began to move. The strong shaking lasted about twelve seconds. In that time a hospital building leaned two feet out of true, a freeway overpass dropped onto a street, and a dam above hundreds of thousands of sleeping people came close to failing. The San Fernando earthquake, called the Sylmar earthquake in Los Angeles because the damage clustered around that northern edge of the city, was a magnitude 6.6 event. It is remembered less than the 1994 Northridge earthquake that came twenty-three years later, but a good part of the rules that protected the city in 1994 were written because of what happened in 1971.

What happened

The quake began on a thrust fault in the foothills of the San Gabriel Mountains, at the northern end of the Valley. Seismologists rate it 6.5 on the surface-wave scale and 6.6 on the moment magnitude scale, and the maximum shaking intensity reached category XI, the top of the Modified Mercalli range. The official death toll attributed directly to the quake is 58, with some counts a little higher because heart attacks and other health-related deaths are tallied differently. Estimates of the injured run from about 200 to as many as 2,000, depending on how the counting is done. Total damage was put at between roughly $505 million and $553 million in the dollars of the time.

The morning itself

Most of the city was asleep. The quake hit at 6:00 a.m. on a weekday in February, before commuters reached the freeways and before the schools opened, a timing that kept the toll well below what a daytime event might have produced. In the hospitals the timing cut the other way: patients were in their beds and the night shift was still on duty. The heavy damage at the Veterans Administration campus came from buildings designed before California's first seismic rules for public structures, and the people inside were the ones least able to get out.

The emergency response worked with the technology of its day. Radio and television carried the news; there were no text alerts and no online maps. Residents below the Van Norman dams learned of the evacuation from emergency officials and from broadcasts. The modern system, which includes NotifyLA for city alerts and the county's own notification system, grew out of decades of experience with events like this one. How to sign up is described in Signing up for NotifyLA and Alert LA County.

The hospitals

The deaths were concentrated in two hospital complexes. At the Veterans Administration hospital in Sylmar, four buildings collapsed, and they accounted for a large share of the deaths. All four were among 26 buildings on the campus built before 1933, before California began to require seismic design in public buildings. The VA site was abandoned in 1972 and later became a city park.

At Olive View Hospital the five-story Medical Treatment and Care Building came close to collapsing. It tilted about two feet to the north, and three of its four concrete stair towers fell. The complex held 606 patients and 98 staff that morning, and all three deaths at Olive View occurred in that one building. The hospital was later rebuilt and now operates in Sylmar as Olive View-UCLA Medical Center.

The lesson from those two campuses was simple and uncomfortable. A hospital has to work after an earthquake, so a building that merely does not fall down is not enough; it must keep its structure, water, power and medical gas intact when the patients arrive. That insight led the state, in the years after, to treat hospitals as a special category with stricter design standards. The 1994 earthquake would test the new rules, and a later state law set a deadline for acute-care hospitals to meet seismic requirements; see northridge and the 1994 earthquake: the neighborhood the quake named.

The dam

Above the Sylmar neighborhood sat the Van Norman reservoirs, which hold part of the city's water supply. The Lower Van Norman Dam, built partly with a technique called hydraulic fill, had its upstream slope slump during the shaking. The crest dropped, and the reservoir level stood a few feet from overtopping the damaged earth. For days engineers lowered the water while about 80,000 people living downstream were evacuated; accounts differ on the exact number, and some describe it as tens of thousands. The evacuation lasted four days. The dam never released its water, but the near-miss put the safety of older earthen dams into every discussion of hazards in the Valley.

The city's longer dam story, told in The St. Francis Dam failure of March 12, 1928, was already on the books: the failure of the St. Francis Dam on March 12, 1928 had led California to create a dam safety program. Sylmar in 1971 showed that older embankments like Van Norman needed the same scrutiny.

The record on a concrete wall

At Pacoima Dam, a few miles from the epicenter, a strong-motion instrument recorded a peak horizontal ground acceleration of about 1.25 g, roughly twice the highest value recorded anywhere before. Engineers were astonished. The number showed that the ground could accelerate far faster than building codes assumed, and it fed into the state's decision to expand instrumentation. In 1971 California started the Strong Motion Instrumentation Program, which put sensors in buildings, bridges, dams and other structures so that the next earthquake would produce data on how they actually behaved. The data from that program has informed design standards ever since.

The freeways

The quake also showed how fragile the new freeway system could be. At the Newhall Pass interchange, where Interstate 5 meets the state highway to the north, two bridge sections, each 191 feet long, fell from heights up to 140 feet, along with a support pillar. At the interchange between the Golden State and Foothill freeways, the overpass carrying westbound I-210 traffic to southbound I-5 collapsed onto San Fernando Road, killing two men in a pickup truck. About ten miles of freeways in the northern Valley were substantially disrupted.

The same Newhall Pass interchange fell again in 1994, one of the reasons the state undertook a major program of bridge seismic retrofits afterward. Columns designed as brittle, with too little steel wrapping them, were retrofitted to bend without breaking. That the same structure failed in two earthquakes twenty-three years apart is the best argument for why such retrofits were worth the cost.

What changed in the rules

Several rules were written or tightened in the years after the quake:

  • The Alquist-Priolo Special Studies Zone Act, signed in December 1972. The 1971 quake broke the ground surface along a fault, damaging buildings that stood directly on or over it. The law told the state to map active faults and restrict the construction of occupied buildings across them without geologic study. It remains in force under a new name, the Alquist-Priolo Earthquake Fault Zoning Act.
  • Stricter hospital standards. California legislators passed a hospital seismic safety law in the early 1970s, setting higher standards for new hospital construction and requiring review by state officials.
  • Strong-motion instrumentation, described above, which began in 1971.
  • Further attention to unreinforced and older buildings. The collapsed VA buildings were all older construction. The state had required earthquake-resistant school construction since the Field Act of 1933, after the Long Beach earthquake, but older public and private buildings had no such requirement, and the debate over retrofitting them continued for decades.

Los Angeles's own building code requirements are administered by the Department of Building and Safety, described in Department of Building and Safety, and the city's emergency preparation falls under Los Angeles Emergency Management Department.

The neighborhoods

The damage and the memory cluster in a few places. Sylmar, the northernmost neighborhood in the city, took the worst of the shaking and the hospital damage. Pacoima, next door, was close to the Pacoima Dam and the record acceleration. Both are discussed in Pacoima and Sylmar: the northeast Valley. The 1971 quake did not strike Northridge directly, but the neighborhood and its university sit on the same fault system that would rupture in 1994, which makes the two quakes easy to remember as a pair; see Northridge.

Why the date matters

Anniversaries of earthquakes are mostly used to remind people to prepare, and February 9 is no different. The 1971 anniversary carries a more specific message, though: the buildings that failed were built under rules everyone thought adequate, and the rule changes that followed saved lives later. For a household the lessons are the same as for a hospital. Know what your building is made of and when it was built, secure the things that fall, keep water and supplies, and plan how to reach family. The practical steps are in Earthquake readiness in Los Angeles, and the 1994 lessons are in northridge's lessons for the next big earthquake.

The quake left a small but telling footprint in the city's geography. The VA campus became a park. Olive View was rebuilt as a modern medical center. The dams above Sylmar were reinforced and their reservoirs lowered. And the Newhall Pass interchange, which fell twice, was rebuilt to a standard that, so far, has held.

The city's Emergency Management Department keeps the alert sign-up and preparedness material for households, and the Department of Building and Safety explains the retrofit and permit rules that grew out of these lessons. A household in an older building can start with those two pages to see what applies.

The worst failures of 1971 happened where people were most vulnerable and least able to leave: hospital beds, a freeway at dawn, a neighborhood below a dam. Each of the later reforms targets one of those situations.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic