Blog
Northridge's lessons for the next big earthquake
The January 17, 1994 quake hit at 4:30 a.m. at magnitude 6.7. What failed, what the city and state changed afterward, and what still depends on old buildings.
At 4:30 on the morning of Monday, January 17, 1994, the floor of the San Fernando Valley moved, and most of Los Angeles was asleep because it was a federal holiday. That detail does a good deal of the arithmetic on the toll. The freeways were close to empty. Offices and schools were locked. The shopping centers had not opened. The magnitude was 6.7, and the rupture lay along a blind thrust fault under the Valley floor, not a famous fault with a name on the map. Los Angeles had been told for decades to watch the San Andreas. The quake that hurt most came from somewhere else.
Fifty-seven people died, by the U.S. Geological Survey's account, and the property damage ran into the tens of billions of dollars. Put the same shock at midday on a working Tuesday and those numbers do not hold. Nearly three decades on, the better question is not how bad it was but what broke, and what the city did about each failure. The answer is a list, and most of the items on it are still being worked through.
What the shaking found
Engineers who walked the Valley and the Westside that January came back with a pattern of failures that sorted into a few families.
Soft first stories. The deadliest single site was an apartment complex in the neighborhood of Northridge itself. Three stories, parking at street level, and the ground floor gave way and the upper two came down on top of it. Engineers call the type a soft-story building: big openings for garages or storefronts below, not enough wall to hold against sideways shaking. Wood-frame buildings like this were everywhere in postwar Los Angeles apartment construction, and they were the most dangerous category the quake turned up.
Non-ductile concrete. Older concrete buildings, put up before modern reinforcement rules, can crack and fail all at once instead of bending. Parking structures took the worst of it. The multistory garage at a large Northridge shopping mall partly collapsed, and so did the garage at the Cal State Northridge campus. Concrete frames from the 1960s and earlier fell under the same suspicion.
Steel that was supposed to be safe. The harder discovery came in welded steel moment-frame buildings, the type engineers had counted among the best performers. After the quake, inspectors found cracks in the welded beam-to-column connections of many of them, some hidden behind finishes. Nobody died when one of these came down. The trouble was that a building could look fine and still be compromised. The finding set off a national research effort and changed the building code for new steel frames.
Freeway bridges. Parts of the Santa Monica Freeway, which is Interstate 10, dropped near La Cienega Boulevard, and sections of the Interstate 5 and State Route 14 interchange north of the Valley fell too. Those collapses became the pictures people remember. The bridges were the same kind of design that had been damaged in the 1971 San Fernando quake, and many were already on the schedule for retrofits that had not been finished.
Hospitals. Several were damaged badly enough to evacuate patients. The 1971 quake had already produced rules for hospitals. Northridge showed that the rules did not reach everything.
What Sacramento did
The state's answer came in layers.
Caltrans accelerated its bridge retrofit program, wrapping columns and strengthening connections on hundreds of freeway structures, and not just in Los Angeles but across the state highway system. Caltrans District 7, which covers Los Angeles and Ventura counties, still maintains the structures in this region and posts closures and conditions on QuickMap, the page described in How to read Caltrans QuickMap and the traffic camera map before you drive.
The Legislature tightened the hospital standard. A 1994 law required hospitals to meet seismic standards, with deadlines for the older buildings that were pushed back more than once over the following decades, because retrofitting or replacing them cost so much. The current deadlines are set by the state, and the agency that administers them is the place to read them, not a summary like this one.
The steel-frame code was rewritten after the connection failures, with new connection designs and new inspection practices. At City Hall, the Department of Building and Safety and the council adopted special rules for steel moment-frame buildings that were damaged or at risk. The code is a living document, and each three-year cycle of the California Building Code takes in new research.
What the city did, eventually
After 1994 the city's biggest question was what to do about the older buildings that had not collapsed yet but would. It took more than two decades to answer.
In October 2015 the City Council approved mandatory retrofit ordinances, and the mayor signed them into law the following month. The package covers two kinds of building:
- Soft-story wood-frame buildings built before 1978, with a weak first floor, such as apartment buildings over open parking. Owners must retrofit within a set period after receiving an order from the Department of Building and Safety; reports on the program describe a seven-year compliance period.
- Non-ductile reinforced concrete buildings built before 1978. Owners must have an engineer evaluate the building and, if it is deficient, strengthen it on a much longer timeline; reports describe up to 25 years.
LADBS runs the program and publishes lists of covered buildings on its site. The city estimated that thousands of soft-story buildings fell under the first ordinance, with a smaller but still significant number of concrete buildings under the second. The department keeps the current counts and the status of each building.
As with most mandatory-cost programs, the ordinances were fought over. Property owners worried about the price of structural work. Tenant advocates worried about rent increases and displacement while crews were in the building. The city's rent stabilization system treats seismic retrofit costs in particular ways, and the Housing Department handles that; the basic structure is in What 3 percent means: the Los Angeles Rent Stabilization Ordinance in 2026 and the department record Los Angeles Housing Department. The department that issues the retrofit orders is Department of Building and Safety.
Emergency Management changed after the 1990s too. It runs NotifyLA and coordinates the city's preparedness programs, a story told in NotifyLA and Alert LA County: signing up for emergency alerts. The state and the U.S. Geological Survey have also built an earthquake early-warning system, ShakeAlert, which reaches phones through a state app and through wireless emergency alerts. It cannot predict a quake. It detects one that has already begun and buys a few seconds before the strongest shaking arrives at a given place. In those seconds, the useful move is the one preparedness guides have recommended for years.
What is still not fixed
A plain list, because the lessons of Northridge are not all learned.
- Many older buildings are still on the lists. A retrofit order and a finished retrofit are different things. LADBS posts compliance status, and with timelines this long, some buildings will not be strengthened until the 2030s or later.
- Not every vulnerable building is covered. The ordinances target particular types. Other older structures, including some unreinforced masonry buildings addressed in an earlier city program, fall under different rules.
- Water and gas lines are vulnerable. Northridge broke water mains and gas lines, and fires followed in some places. The Los Angeles Department of Water and Power has since replaced some pipe with earthquake-resistant types, and the long story of the city's water network is in Where Los Angeles gets its water: the aqueduct and LADWP today. Households still need their own emergency water, since the system can be out for days after a major quake.
- The big fault is elsewhere. At 6.7, Northridge was a moderate event by the standards of the region's geology. The San Andreas Fault, along the northern edge of the Los Angeles basin, is capable of a much larger rupture. Planners say "the big one" for that scenario, and the Valley quake is the practical reminder that something smaller and closer can arrive first.
What a household can do
The city's preparedness advice has hardly changed since the 1990s, and it is practical:
- Know your building. If you rent in an older multifamily building with parking underneath, ask your landlord whether it is on the soft-story list. LADBS lists covered buildings by address.
- Secure what falls. Bookcases, water heaters and televisions injure people even in buildings that stay up. Strapping and anchoring cost little next to the harm.
- Drop, cover and hold on. When the shaking starts, drop to the floor, take cover under a sturdy table or against an interior wall away from windows, and hold on until it stops.
- Prepare a kit and a plan. The household kit and the plan for finding each other are covered in An earthquake kit checklist for a Los Angeles household and the guide Earthquake readiness in Los Angeles.
- Sign up for alerts. NotifyLA is the city's emergency notification system; the sign-up is on the Emergency Management Department's site.
January 17
Each January 17 the city marks the anniversary, and each year a few more of the people who remember it from the inside are older. The 1994 quake is among the most studied events in the history of earthquake engineering, and many of the building rules now taken for granted in Los Angeles trace back to that morning. The longer record of the region's quakes includes the 1971 event in Sylmar, told in The February 9, 1971 Sylmar earthquake and what it taught the city, and the Valley that took both shocks is described in northridge and the 1994 earthquake: the neighborhood the quake named.
The lesson that holds up best is a modest one. The quake that arrives is rarely the one the planners expected, so the sound investment is in what makes any quake less deadly: buildings that bend instead of break, gas lines that do not burn, and households that already know where the water is stored.