Blog
The 1926 ballot fight that built Union Station
A non-binding 1926 vote asked where to build a union rail terminal. The answer was set aside, Chinatown was cleared and the station opened in May 1939.
Stand on the Alameda Street sidewalk some weekday morning and the argument is right there, three lanes wide. To the west are the Plaza and Olvera Street, where the city began. To the east, behind the long Spanish-looking facade, is Union Station. A few hundred feet separate them. In 1926 that distance was the whole fight.
That February, Los Angeles voters were handed two questions about a building that did not exist. Proposition 8 asked whether the city should work toward a single union passenger terminal for the railroads that served it. Proposition 9 asked whether that terminal should go at the Los Angeles Plaza, the old center of town beside Olvera Street. Both passed. Proposition 8 won with 61.3 percent of the vote and Proposition 9 with 51.1 percent. Neither was binding.
Thirteen years later a terminal opened. It was not at the Plaza. It stood across the street, on land that was then Chinatown, and the people who lived and worked there had to leave. Today the station is among the best-loved buildings in the region. It is also one of the plainest examples of a public vote being set aside by people with more power than the voters.
Three depots and a city that needed one
In the mid-1920s a traveler arriving in Los Angeles by train could not simply step onto another. Passenger service was divided among competing railroads, each with a depot of its own. Southern Pacific used Central Station. The Santa Fe used La Grande Station. Union Pacific trains used Salt Lake Station. The three were not close to one another, and none sat at the center of Downtown in the way a modern terminal would. Trains crossed busy streets at grade, a hazard and a delay that grew worse as automobile traffic grew.
A union terminal, one station shared by every railroad, had been talked about for years. By 1925 the railroads had put an offer on the table: they would build elevated tracks at their own expense, which would end the grade crossings, if the city and the state could agree on a location. A union station promised a more efficient network and a single front door for the city. The quarrel was over where that door should be.
What the ballot did and did not decide
In February 1926 the City Council put non-binding questions before the voters. Did they want a union terminal? Should it be at the Plaza? The first was a clear yes. The second was close: 51.1 percent in favor, 48.9 percent opposed.
"Non-binding" was the word that mattered. A city council could not build a railroad terminal on its own authority. The railroads owned the track and would have to agree. The ballot was a reading of public opinion, not a decision, and that left room for anyone who wanted a different outcome to keep working.
The Plaza site carried its own trouble. It lay beside the old Chinatown, a district of brick buildings, businesses and homes that dated to the 1880s. Putting the terminal there meant removing the neighborhood or building across it. The debate took on racial overtones, and arguments about rail alignment ran together with prejudice against the people who lived next door.
The reversal
Despite the vote for the Plaza, the station went up across the street, on the Chinatown site. Two figures did the most to bring that about. One was the preservationist Christine Sterling, who wanted to protect the Plaza and the Avila Adobe, and who in 1930 led the effort to turn nearby Olvera Street into a Mexican marketplace; see El Pueblo de Los Angeles and the Avila Adobe, built in 1818. The other was Harry Chandler, publisher of the Los Angeles Times, whose newspaper gave him wide influence in the city's business and political circles.
The result was a compromise that spared the Plaza and cleared the neighborhood to its east. The final siting was settled by negotiation, not at the ballot box. The ballot question of 1926 had asked about a building. It had not asked about the people who were in its way.
Clearing Chinatown
The first Chinatown of Los Angeles stood on and around Alameda Street and Macy Street. It had grown since the 1880s into a district of merchants, laundries, groceries and family associations, in the shadow of the Plaza where the city began in 1781. The terminal's footprint covered it. By the 1930s the buildings were coming down, and the community had to find a new home.
The answer was New Chinatown, which opened in 1938 a few blocks north around Central Plaza. Chinese American merchants led its development with the help of Hollywood designers. The move was not voluntary, and later generations have told it both as a story of displacement and as one of rebuilding. A walk through Chinatown, from the Civic Center edge to the gates follows the streets of both places, and Chinese food in Los Angeles, from Old Chinatown to the San Gabriel Valley covers the community's food.
Another history lay under the site. During construction, archaeological remains were uncovered of Yaanga, the Tongva village that stood near the river before the Spanish pueblo was founded. That village is the subject of Yaanga: the Indigenous village the pueblo grew beside. The ground at Union Station holds three layers of settlement: an Indigenous village, a Chinese American neighborhood and a railroad terminal.
Building the terminal
The Los Angeles Union Passenger Terminal opened on May 3, 1939, at a cost of $11 million in 1939 dollars. The architects were the father-and-son team of John and Donald Parkinson, with support from the architect Jan van der Linden, and the contractor was Robert E. McKee Inc. The station replaced the three older depots, among them La Grande Station, which had been damaged in the 1933 Long Beach earthquake.
The design borrows from several styles. Art Deco, Mission Revival and Streamline Moderne all show up, arranged so that the building reads Spanish Colonial from the street and modern inside. A few features stand out:
- The ticket lobby, with ceilings 62 feet high and a counter 110 feet long.
- Travertine marble on the lower interior walls.
- The grand waiting room, whose ceiling looks like wood but is steel.
- The restaurant. The Harvey House restaurant was designed by Mary Colter and was the last Harvey House built as part of a passenger terminal. It closed in 1967 and sat largely empty for decades. After a four-year renovation, the space reopened in October 2018 as a beer hall, and its cocktail lounge reopened as The Streamliner.
- The track layout, with six island platforms serving 14 tracks.
The address is 800 North Alameda Street. It is the largest passenger rail terminal in the western United States, and it has a second career as a location for many movies. Union Station: a walk through the terminal that opened in 1939 goes through the building room by room.
A terminal for the transit age
Union Station opened at the tail end of the great era of passenger rail, and for decades after the Second World War it was quieter than its builders had imagined. The Los Angeles Metropolitan Transit Authority was created in 1951; From the 1951 Metropolitan Transit Authority to today's Metro follows how that agency became today's Metro. In recent decades the station has found new life as a hub. Metro's rail lines and buses stop here, Metrolink commuter trains run to destinations across Southern California, and Amtrak serves intercity routes, with a lounge for its passengers on site. Metrolink from Union Station, how commuter rail serves Greater Los Angeles describes the regional trains, and Using Metro buses and trains: fares, caps and tapping explains Metro fares.
So the logic of 1926 has come around again. A single central station connecting rail lines and buses is what the voters were asking for, and the building the railroads put up is the place that now does it.
Reading the building today
The 1926 argument can still be traced in the station's layout. The terminal sits on the east side of Alameda, with the Plaza and Olvera Street directly across to the west, so the two sites the voters were choosing between face each other over a few lanes of traffic. From the sidewalk between them the choice looks small, which is partly why it was so bitter: a few hundred feet decided which neighborhood stayed and which was cleared.
Inside, the ticket lobby and the grand waiting room are still the best rooms for understanding what the Parkinsons designed. Tall arched windows, courtyards planted for shade and that long ticket counter were meant to make a rail journey feel like an occasion. Outdoor courtyards on either side of the main building give the station a garden quality unusual in a rail terminal. The old Harvey House dining space recalls the years when railroad companies ran restaurants for travelers, and its 2018 reopening as a beer hall and lounge shows a building that has been put to use rather than kept as a museum.
The station also sits at the center of the city's transit planning. Metro's rail network converges here, and the agency's own history is tied up with the property. Ride the A Line in from Chinatown or Little Tokyo and you step off into a building whose location was fought over a century ago.
What the story shows
Three lessons come out of the episode.
- Ballot results can be advisory. A vote that is not binding does not bind anyone, and in 1926 the people who owned the tracks and the land had more say than the people who cast the ballots.
- Infrastructure has a human footprint. The land that held the terminal had been home to people, and their removal was treated as a detail. Later projects, from freeways to stadiums, have set off similar debates; see Chavez Ravine before Dodger Stadium.
- A building can outlast its reasons. The compromise that put the station on the Chinatown site was not made with the community's interests in mind, yet the building has become a civic treasure the city now protects.
Readers who want to see where those decisions were recorded can start with the City Clerk, whose archives hold council actions and ordinances of the period; the Office of the City Clerk profile explains how. The station itself is open to the public and a visit takes a few minutes: step into the ticket lobby, look up at the ceiling, then walk out to the street where a neighborhood once stood.