Blog

Chavez Ravine before Dodger Stadium

From Julián Chávez's 83 acres to three hillside neighborhoods, a public-housing plan and the 1958 vote that handed the ravine to the Dodgers.

Look north from Downtown toward Elysian Park and a hillside climbs to a parking lot the size of a small town. The ballpark on top is the oldest in Major League Baseball west of the Mississippi, and it opened in 1962 at a cost of $23 million. But the ground under the lot has a history that long predates the stadium, and the families who lived there remain part of how Angelenos talk about the place. The ravine's story runs in order: a rancher's purchase, three hillside neighborhoods, a public-housing plan that was never built, and the vote that sent a baseball team up the hill.

The ravine and the man it is named for

Chavez Ravine is named for Julián Chávez, a leader from New Mexico who moved to Los Angeles in the early 1830s. In 1844 he bought 83 acres in the valley between the hills north of the pueblo. The land was steep, dry and unremarkable for farming, but it was close to the town and to the river that supplied it. The name stuck even after the land was divided, sold and subdivided in the decades that followed.

By the 1880s the area was being put to other uses. In 1886 part of it became Elysian Park, a reminder that the hills above the pueblo were protected as open space even as the flats grew. That same year, two brick manufacturers began blasting the hillsides for clay, and the blasting went on for decades. Elysian Park is still managed by the city's Recreation and Parks Department, profiled in Los Angeles Department of Recreation and Parks.

Three hillside neighborhoods

In the early 1900s, three Mexican-American neighborhoods took shape on the ridges of the ravine: Palo Verde, La Loma and Bishop. They were small communities of houses on hillside lots, at the edge of the city and out of sight of Downtown. Families had come up from the river floodplain, where floods were a threat: in 1913 a lawyer named Marshall Stimson subsidized the move of about 250 Mexican Americans from the Los Angeles River's flood-prone banks to the ravine.

Residents lived with real hardships. The brick quarries and their blasting menaced homes. Then, on August 20, 1926, the City Council unanimously banned blasting in the area and zoned it for residential use. The vote reads as a turning point: the area was legally a neighborhood, and the people who lived there had won protection from the industry working beside them.

The planners arrive

In the 1940s, city officials began to label the area "blighted." That was an official category, and it carried consequences: under the federal Housing Act of 1949, cities could use federal funds to clear areas judged substandard and to build public housing in their place. A well-known architect, Richard Neutra, together with Robert Alexander, planned a public-housing development for the ravine called Elysian Park Heights. The design was ambitious: two dozen 13-story buildings along with more than 160 two-story townhouses.

To assemble the land, the city used eminent domain. That is, the government bought out homeowners and took properties at a price set by the process. Some residents sold and left. Others held out, and the question of what they would be paid, and whether they could return to the new housing once it was built, became a source of bitterness. As the homes of those who left were demolished, a few families stayed in place while the legal and political battle turned.

The politics change

Then the politics shifted. In 1953, Norris Poulson was elected mayor on a platform that included opposition to public housing, which he called un-American. Support for Elysian Park Heights faded. The project was cancelled, and the city repurchased the land from the Federal Housing Authority at a reduced price. That left the city with a large tract of cleared or partly cleared land in the middle of town, a fact that would soon matter.

In those same years a baseball team was looking for a new home. The Brooklyn Dodgers, owned by Walter O'Malley, wanted a bigger stadium than Ebbets Field and had found that New York would not give him the land he wanted. Los Angeles, which had never had a major-league team, wanted one. The ravine, owned by the city and vacant, became the center of a deal.

The 1958 vote

The proposed arrangement: the city would trade 352 acres in Chavez Ravine to the Dodgers in exchange for land around Wrigley Field, a minor-league ballpark in South Los Angeles, and the team would build a stadium at its own expense. Opponents argued that public land should not be handed to a private business, and they doubted the cost to taxpayers. Supporters saw major-league baseball as a mark of a city's arrival, and some thought the ravine's long neglect justified any use that would develop it.

Voters decided. On June 3, 1958, they approved what became known as the baseball referendum. The Dodgers moved to Los Angeles that year and played at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum from 1958 to 1961 while the ravine was prepared. A longer look at the Coliseum, which has hosted two Olympic Games, is in The Coliseum and two Olympics: USC's home since 1923.

The other ballpark

The land the Dodgers gave up in the trade surrounded Wrigley Field, a Pacific Coast League ballpark in South Los Angeles built in the 1920s and named for the chewing-gum magnate who owned the minor-league Angels. The swap had a plain logic for the city: a team that had never played in the region would get a large site, and the city would get a ballpark site in return. For the team the appeal was space. Chavez Ravine offered hundreds of acres within sight of the civic center, enough for a stadium and acres of parking, with roads being built through the nearby hills.

The first years in Los Angeles were improvised. The team's home for four seasons, the Coliseum, was built for track and football, and its odd dimensions shaped how baseball was played there. The 1959 World Series, the team's first in its new city, was played at the Coliseum before enormous crowds. Then the stadium on the hill opened, and the improvised years ended.

The last holdouts

The families who stayed in the ravine after the land changed hands became a national story. In May 1959, county sheriff's deputies removed members of the Arechiga family from their home in Palo Verde. A newspaper photo of the scene ran on the front page the next day. They were among the last residents in the neighborhood, and their eviction has been remembered ever since as the picture of what the ravine's residents lost. Historians differ about the details of the family's property rights and the circumstances, and accounts of the day vary in small ways. What is not in dispute is that by 1962 the neighborhoods of Palo Verde, La Loma and Bishop no longer existed. The hills had been graded, the streets removed, and a stadium built.

What was built

Dodger Stadium opened in 1962. It was built into the hillside, with parking lots stepping down the slope on every side, so fans arrive at the upper rim and descend into the seats. The design is a product of the freeway era, built around the car. It has a history of its own now, World Series and generations of fans, told in A game day at Dodger Stadium: arriving, parking and finding your seat. Getting there without driving has become a real question in the years since; Getting to Dodger Stadium without a car covers the options.

Around the stadium, the rest of the former ravine is a mix of uses. Elysian Park continues above it. The residential neighborhoods nearby, including Echo Park, have a different history but share the hills and the sense of living above the city center. Echo Park Lake and the hills toward Dodger Stadium connects the two. Some of the area's older residents and their descendants have continued to gather to remember the old neighborhoods, and the ravine has been the subject of books, music, photography and a play. It is one of the stories most often used to explain what urban renewal did to Los Angeles.

How to read it today

The ravine's history carries more than one lesson, and people draw different ones.

  • For those who emphasize the loss, it shows how a city can classify a neighborhood as blighted and clear it, promise something better and then change course. The families who lived there were poor, but they had a community, and the redevelopment that replaced it did not benefit them.
  • For those who emphasize the politics, it shows how a public-housing project could fail because of the political climate of the 1950s, and how a city that had already cleared the land would then look for another use for it.
  • For those who emphasize the result, it shows how a ballpark became a civic institution, with a place in the memory of millions of people who never knew what was there before.

All three readings are supported by the record, and the record is clear on the sequence: a rancher's purchase in 1844; three neighborhoods in the early 1900s; a blasting ban in 1926; a housing plan in the late 1940s; a mayor's change of course in 1953; a vote on June 3, 1958; and a stadium in 1962. The Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, profiled in Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, still runs public housing in the city, and the planning questions that shaped the ravine are still decided at Department of City Planning.

If you go to a game, take a minute at the top of the parking lot and look back toward Downtown. The view the ravine's residents had is the same one the fans have now.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic