Blog

Chinese food in Los Angeles, from Old Chinatown to the San Gabriel Valley

How Chinese cooking in Los Angeles moved from Old Chinatown to Union Station's footprint, to New Chinatown in 1938, and then east to the San Gabriel Valley.

Ask a longtime Angeleno where to find the best Chinese food in the city and the answer will probably not be Chinatown. It will be a strip mall twelve miles east, in a city called Monterey Park or Alhambra or San Gabriel, with a lot full of cars and a line out the door at 11 a.m. on Sunday. That is the twist. The neighborhood called Chinatown is the older center, the one with the history and the gates and the red lanterns, but the main concentration of Chinese restaurants in the region left it decades ago. To see why, go back to the 1800s, through two different Chinatowns and a train station, and out along the Valley Boulevard corridor.

The first Chinatown, and what happened in 1871

Chinese immigrants began arriving in California in large numbers during the Gold Rush in the 1850s, and some settled in Los Angeles, then a small pueblo with a plaza at its center. They worked as laborers, launderers, vegetable growers and cooks, and by the 1880s a district known as Old Chinatown stood around Alameda and Macy Streets, east of the plaza. The Macy Street of that era is now Cesar Chavez Avenue.

The community's early history includes one of the darkest episodes in the city's past. On October 24, 1871, a mob entered the Chinese quarter and killed about twenty Chinese men and boys in a lynching and massacre. It is remembered as one of the largest mass killings of its kind in American history, and it happened when the whole city had a few thousand residents. The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which barred new Chinese laborers from immigrating, followed, and for decades the community in Los Angeles stayed small, aging and mostly male.

Restaurants in that world were practical places. They fed workers, and the dishes that reached the wider public were adaptations: chop suey, chow mein, egg foo young and other Cantonese-American dishes made from what could be had in Southern California. The food of Old Chinatown was no copy of what was cooked in Guangdong. It was something new, built by cooks working with local produce for an audience that included many non-Chinese diners. The same pattern shows up across the country, and it is part of the history of American Chinese food, not a lesser version of it.

Union Station and the move to New Chinatown

Old Chinatown did not survive the 1930s. After a long political fight, the city chose the site for the new Los Angeles Union Station, which opened in May 1939 as the Los Angeles Union Passenger Terminal. The Old Chinatown buildings were cleared to make room. Parts of the old settlement turned up in later decades when excavation began for the Metro subway. The station's own story is told in Union Station: a walk through the terminal that opened in 1939 and The 1926 ballot fight that built Union Station.

The community did not vanish. In 1938, a year before the station opened, New Chinatown opened for business a few blocks north. Community leaders, Peter Soo Hoo Sr. among them, helped shape its design, and Hollywood set designers built the Central Plaza, which includes Gin Ling Way and Chung King Road. The result was part neighborhood and part stage set: pagoda rooflines, courtyards and gateways meant to look the way a visiting audience imagined China, built by and for people who were also running their own businesses and raising their own families.

That same year saw the opening of China City, a separate tourist-oriented district developed by a Los Angeles civic activist named Christine Sterling. It was rebuilt after a fire in its first year and closed for good after a second fire in 1948. New Chinatown, by contrast, survived, and in 1939 it celebrated its first anniversary with an enormous cake lettered with the words "chop suey."

For the next several decades, Chinatown was the center of Chinese life in Los Angeles. Restaurants served family banquets, banquet halls hosted weddings, and the stores sold groceries, herbs and gifts. Today it is a compact, walkable district, with the Metro A Line stopping in the middle of it. Chinatown describes the neighborhood, and A walk through Chinatown, from the Civic Center edge to the gates takes it street by street.

Why the restaurants moved east

Two changes pushed Chinese life in Southern California out of the old center.

The first was who was coming. The Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 ended the national-origins quotas that had limited immigration from Asia for decades. In the 1970s and after, new immigrants arrived from Taiwan, Hong Kong and mainland China, among them professionals, students and families with money to buy houses. Many wanted single-family homes, good schools and shopping centers with parking, and Chinatown, a dense district with little room, was not that.

The second was the geography of the suburbs. Monterey Park, just east of Downtown, became one of the first places where a new wave of Chinese immigrants settled and where Chinese-owned businesses clustered. From there the community spread eastward through Alhambra, San Gabriel, Rosemead, Arcadia and on into the east San Gabriel Valley. By the end of the twentieth century, many of Chinatown's former residents had moved to Monterey Park, and restaurant activity had shifted with them to the San Gabriel Valley.

The pattern is plain in the shape of the region. The Valley's main commercial streets, Valley Boulevard, Garvey Avenue, Atlantic Boulevard and others, are lined with strip malls where one parking lot can hold a dim sum hall, a noodle shop, a bakery and a hot pot restaurant. The restaurants do not scatter. They cluster, because a diner who arrives for one meal will stay for a second stop, and because a landlord who fills a mall with restaurants draws a crowd for all of them.

What the food became

Once the community had the space and the customers, Chinese cooking in Los Angeles widened far beyond chop suey. The San Gabriel Valley's restaurants came to represent most of the major regional traditions of China and nearby places, including:

  • Cantonese cooking and dim sum, served from carts or on order sheets, with steamed dumplings, buns, rice rolls and roasted meats.
  • Hong Kong-style cafes, which serve milk tea, toast, baked rice dishes and noodle soups at all hours.
  • Sichuan cooking, with numbing peppercorn and chile heat that bears little resemblance to the sweeter dishes of the old Chinese-American menu.
  • Shanghai and Jiangnan dishes, including soup dumplings and braised pork.
  • Northern noodle and dumpling traditions, such as hand-pulled and knife-cut noodles.
  • Taiwanese cooking, from beef noodle soup to night-market snacks and shaved-ice desserts.

The Valley's menu is not static. As new immigrants arrive from different regions, new kinds of restaurants appear, and the older ones adapt. This is a story of continuing arrival, not a single transplant. Comfort food classics of Los Angeles looks at the more familiar dishes in the city's food scene, and Why restaurants close in Los Angeles: rents, labor and the calendar covers how the economics of the last few years have changed which places survive.

Two places, two kinds of visit

The older center and the newer corridor do different jobs now, and it helps to know which to choose.

Chinatown San Gabriel Valley
Setting Compact, walkable plaza and streets near Downtown Long commercial boulevards, mostly strip malls
Getting there Metro A Line station in the middle of the district By car for most trips; parking lots are shared
Character History, architecture, galleries, a gateway to Downtown Large restaurants, regional specialties, grocery stores
Best for A short visit combined with Union Station and the Plaza A meal-focused trip, often with several stops

Neither replaces the other. Chinatown is where the community has a symbolic and historical home, with cultural institutions and festivals tied to the neighborhood, and it has seen new galleries and housing arrive in recent years. The San Gabriel Valley is where much of the daily life of the Chinese-American community, and much of the restaurant economy, is now based.

A few habits that help a visit

  • Go at off-peak hours. Dim sum halls fill by late morning on weekends. Arriving early or in the middle of the afternoon cuts the wait.
  • Bring a group. Many Valley restaurants are built around shared dishes, and a table of four or six can order a much wider range than a couple.
  • Check health grades. Los Angeles County posts a letter grade at the door of every restaurant, and Reading a Los Angeles restaurant grade card explains how to read it.
  • Combine, do not rank. Better than asking for "the best" restaurant: pick a street and walk or drive along it. The strip-mall clusters reward browsing.
  • Pair Chinatown with its neighbors. A visit to the plaza fits naturally with a walk to Union Station and the Plaza at El Pueblo, and Little Tokyo is a short ride away; see Little Tokyo.

Why this history matters

The map of Chinese food in Los Angeles is a map of immigration law, urban renewal and suburban growth. Old Chinatown was cleared for a railroad station. New Chinatown was built on a new site in 1938 because the community insisted on having a place of its own. Later, when the law changed and new immigrants arrived, the center of gravity moved again, east, to the suburbs where housing was available. Every shift left a mark on the menus.

So the answer to the opening question depends on what you want. For the history, go to Chinatown. For a Sunday meal with three generations around a round table, the answer is probably in a strip mall in the San Gabriel Valley, and the drive there is the same drive the community took.

Related neighborhoods

Related guides

Latest on this topic