Blog

Comfort food classics of Los Angeles

The French dip, the Cobb salad, the pushcart hot dog and the Jewish deli: the stories behind the dishes Angelenos claim as their own.

This city is famous for its trends, yet its comfort food is old. The dishes locals order without opening the menu arrive with origin stories, rival claims and a few legends nobody can quite prove. Several were invented at counters and lunchrooms in the first half of the twentieth century, by cooks improvising for a customer or for themselves, and they stuck because a city of newcomers needed something familiar. What follows is a short history of a handful of them, told through the places that made them famous, with the arguments left in.

The French dip and a century-old argument

A French dip is roast beef on a roll, sliced thin, the bread dipped in the pan juices, with a cup of the same juice on the side. Two Downtown restaurants, both opened in 1908, say they invented it, and the argument has run for generations.

Philippe the Original opened in October 1908 on Alameda Street, a short walk from the plaza where the city began and from Union Station. The restaurant's own account is that in 1918 the owner, Philippe Mathieu, was making a sandwich when he accidentally dropped the roll into a hot pan of roasting juices, and the customer liked the result. Cole's, which opened the same year on Sixth Street on the ground floor of the Pacific Electric Building, tells a different story: a chef named Jack Garlinghouse made the first one for a customer who complained of sore gums, and the bread was dipped to soften it. Cole's closed in 2007 and reopened in 2008, and was designated a Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument in 1989.

The record is modest. Both places opened in 1908. The sandwich itself began to appear in print in the 1930s, and the first printed links tied it to Philippe's, with Cole's claim documented later. Food historians who have looked at the question lean toward Philippe's, though the stories on both sides are passed down inside the restaurants, and the debate has never been settled. Locals tend not to care. The point is that a sandwich was reinvented in a city building a restaurant culture almost from scratch. Whichever place was first, the dish says something about the downtown of the 1900s, a world of rail terminals, newspapers and lunch counters. For the neighborhood around Philippe's, see Chinatown, and for the historic core where Cole's stands, see Downtown's Historic Core, a walk from Pershing Square to Spring Street.

The Cobb salad, a Hollywood late-night snack

The Cobb salad, chopped greens topped with rows of chicken, bacon, egg, avocado, tomato and blue cheese, is a Hollywood invention. The standard story is that in 1937 the owner of the Brown Derby, Bob Cobb, went looking for a late-night snack in the restaurant's kitchen and assembled one from whatever he found, with bacon added from a cook. The next day, a theater owner who had been given a taste asked for "a Cobb salad," and the name took.

As with the French dip, the details are disputed. Some accounts date it to 1937 or 1938, and others credit the restaurant's chef. What is certain is that the Brown Derby, with locations on Wilshire Boulevard and in Hollywood, was where studio people ate, and that the dish traveled with the people who ate there. More than four million were reported sold at Brown Derby restaurants over the decades. The original restaurants have closed, though the name is licensed, and the salad is still on menus across the country. It is a food of Hollywood in the literal sense: a dish for people who ate at odd hours, for whom the kitchen was an extension of the set. The area's fuller story is in Hollywood and hollywood and cocktails: the bar culture of the studio era.

The pushcart hot dog

Pink's began in 1939 as a pushcart at La Brea Avenue and Melrose Avenue, run by Paul and Betty Pink, who sold hot dogs for ten cents. The Pinks later bought the lot they had been renting, and the cart became a permanent stand, which most accounts date to the mid-1940s. Paul and Betty retired in 1985, and their children took over. The stand is still at the same intersection, and the line out front is a fixture. Pink's is a modest idea that stayed in one place long enough to become a landmark: the hot dog is not a Los Angeles invention, but the place became part of the city's story of itself. It also shows how the city's streets, and its car culture, shaped the food. A stand at a busy intersection did not need a dining room.

The Jewish deli tradition

Delicatessens belong on any list of Los Angeles comfort food, and the city's version is a story of migration within the country as much as from abroad. Canter's was founded in 1931 in Boyle Heights, then a heavily Jewish neighborhood on the east side, and later moved to the Fairfax District, where it took over a former movie theater. The Fairfax area's identity as a center of Jewish life, described in Fairfax District and The Fairfax District: a neighborhood walk along Fairfax Avenue, helped keep the deli tradition alive on the west side as Boyle Heights changed. Langer's Delicatessen opened in June 1947, with about a dozen seats, on Alvarado Street across from MacArthur Park, and it is still known for a hot pastrami sandwich on rye. The restaurant sits in Westlake, a few steps from the Metro station that bears the park's name. The restaurant says it nearly closed in the early 1990s before business recovered.

What these places share is more than pastrami. It is the habit of eating a big meal at a counter or a booth in a restaurant that has stayed in the same family for decades, in a city where most places change hands every few years.

How a lunch counter became a landmark

Look at the years on these dishes and a pattern shows. Cole's and Philippe's opened in 1908. Canter's followed in 1931, Pink's in 1939 and Langer's in 1947. Each opened in a different decade of a city growing fast, and each opened where the customers were: near the rail terminals and newspapers of the old downtown, along a boulevard of studios, on a corner where cars slowed down, across from a park in a neighborhood full of new arrivals. A restaurant that fits a place and a time and then stays put is rare in Los Angeles, which is why the survivors carry so much weight.

Staying put is also a matter of the buildings. Cole's occupies the ground floor of the Pacific Electric Building, headquarters of the interurban railway that once tied the region together. Its designation as a Historic-Cultural Monument in 1989 reflects how the city has come to treat its old commercial rooms as part of its heritage. The city's planning department, Department of City Planning, runs the historic-resources program under which such designations are handled.

Ordering, and what to know

A few practical notes for first-timers:

  • Expect lines at peak hours. Lunch and weekend evenings are crowded at the best-known places, and several take no reservations at all.
  • Ask what the house is known for. The staff will point you to the signature item without being asked twice, and it is usually what regulars order.
  • Check the restaurant's grade. The county's letter grade is posted in the window; Reading a Los Angeles restaurant grade card explains how it is scored.
  • Think about how you get there. Several of these places are near Metro stations, and parking in the surrounding blocks follows the rules in Reading a Los Angeles parking sign without getting a ticket.

The food of the city's newcomers

The dishes above are the ones with documented founding stories. The most common comfort foods in Los Angeles belong to the communities who built it, and they rarely have a single inventor.

These traditions overlap, and what Angelenos call comfort food is often a dish from a home that was not their own. A plate of rice, beans and a stew can be eaten in many languages.

Why a classic lasts

A few things the survivors share:

  1. A fixed menu item that people can name. "The dip," "the Cobb," "the pastrami," "the chili dog." People come back for a specific thing.
  2. A location that has not moved far. Several of the places above are in the same neighborhoods where they opened.
  3. A rhythm of lines and regulars. The queue at lunch is part of the product.
  4. A story, true or not. The origin dispute helps the dish more than it hurts it.

The list is not a ranking, and it is not a map of where to eat. For a way to think about restaurants in general, including how to read the county's grade cards, see Reading a Los Angeles restaurant grade card. For a longer tour of the city's food by neighborhood, the A guide to Los Angeles neighborhoods and districts is a good starting point. The classics are worth knowing whether or not you stand in the line, because they show how a city of migrants made itself a menu.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic