Blog
The Los Angeles Star and the city's first newspapers
The bilingual Star began May 17, 1851 and ran until 1879, setting the pattern for local news; its history runs through the Civil War and the Times era.
Four pages, two in English and two in Spanish: that was the first issue of the Los Angeles Star, dated May 17, 1851, and printed in a town that had been a United States city for barely a year. The place had no public library and no paved street, but it had a newspaper, and the newspaper spoke two languages because the town did. The Star lasted twenty-eight years, nearly the whole of the city's frontier period, and it set the pattern for how Los Angeles would learn about itself: through the printed page, argued over, paid for by advertising and legal notices, and always at the mercy of whoever held the press.
A town of a few thousand
When the Star began, Los Angeles was a small pueblo in a very large county. It had been founded in 1781, passed from Spain to Mexico to the United States, and incorporated as an American city on April 4, 1850, five months before California became a state. Its streets had been surveyed only two years earlier, in 1849, when Lieutenant Edward Ord extended the grid and set off the city's first real-estate boom. By 1890 the city's population would reach about 50,400 and the county's 101,454, but in 1851 it was a ranching town of adobe houses around a plaza. The founding of the pueblo on September 4, 1781 covers the founding, April 4, 1850: Los Angeles becomes an American city the incorporation and Edward Ord's 1849 survey and the city's first real-estate boom the survey.
Into that town came two men, John Allen Lewis and John McElroy, to start a paper. A third partner, Theodore Foster, who had received a city lot to build a printing office, dropped out before the first issue. William H. Rand bought into the venture in July 1851. The paper came off a hand press, and its output was small: a weekly sheet a subscriber could read in an evening.
Two languages on one page
The first issue carried two pages in English and two in Spanish, and the choice shows how the town saw itself. In 1851 a large share of Los Angeles residents spoke Spanish as their first language, among them the landowners, rancheros and townspeople whose families had been in California since the Spanish and Mexican periods, and many of the people who worked for them. An English-only paper would have missed much of its audience, and the editors knew that laws, notices and elections affected everyone.
The Spanish section ran until 1855. The same year, a separate Spanish-language paper, El Clamor Público, began publication under the editor Francisco P. Ramírez, and it carried a distinct voice on the rights and concerns of Spanish-speaking Californians. The history of those two papers, one bilingual and then English, one in Spanish, is a short history of the city's changing population in the 1850s, as English-speaking settlers shifted the balance of the town.
What a frontier paper did
A newspaper in 1850s Los Angeles looked nothing like a newspaper today. It did several jobs at once:
- It printed the law. Legal notices, city ordinances, tax lists and court announcements ran in the paper, and the fees for printing them were a main source of income. A paper that held the contract for official notices had a stable business.
- It carried advertising. Merchants, lawyers, doctors, land agents and steamship lines bought space, and the advertisements are one of the best records of what the town sold and who lived there.
- It reprinted the news. News from San Francisco, from the East and from Europe arrived by ship and later by telegraph and was then copied from other papers. A paper's "exchanges," the other newspapers it received by mail, supplied much of what it printed.
- It argued about politics. Papers were partisan, and editors did not hide their positions. The Star's pages followed the debates over land titles, county government and the split between north and south in California, including the 1859 vote described in The 1859 vote to split southern California off as a new territory called Colorado.
- It recorded local life. Weather, crops, accidents, crimes, visitors, weddings and deaths filled the columns of a paper that served a small community.
That mix made the paper both a business and a public institution, and it is why the Star is a source for historians of the period.
Weekly and then daily
The Star was a weekly for most of its life. It added a daily edition beginning June 1, 1870, a sign that the city was growing. A daily newspaper needs a daily audience: enough readers within walking distance to buy it, and enough advertisers to pay for it. In 1851 Los Angeles could not support that. By 1870, it nearly could.
The Civil War years
The Civil War divided Los Angeles, where many residents had Southern sympathies, and the Star sat in the middle. In 1864 the paper was suspended after its editor, Henry Hamilton, was arrested for Confederate sympathies, a reminder that wartime politics could end a newspaper's run. The Star resumed publication in May 1868. The episode shows something about the press of the era: the editor's politics were the paper's politics, and a change in the political climate could shut it down.
Competition and the end of the Star
The Star was not alone for long. Other papers arrived, some short-lived and some more durable. The Los Angeles Daily Herald began in 1873 and grew into a major paper in the following decades. The Los Angeles Times began on December 4, 1881, as the Los Angeles Daily Times, and went on to dominate the city's news for more than a century.
The Star's own end came in 1879, when the county sheriff attached the paper for debt. It was a prosaic ending for the city's first newspaper: no dramatic closing, just a bankruptcy, the common fate of papers that could not keep up with competition or pay their bills. By then the city had changed. The railroad arrived in the 1870s and 1880s, the population surged, and the town that had read the Star's four-page weekly was becoming one that wanted a daily with telegraph news and many pages of advertisements. A paper from the pueblo era did not fit the new city.
The Star in dates
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| May 17, 1851 | First issue, two pages in English and two in Spanish |
| July 1851 | William H. Rand buys into the paper |
| 1855 | The Spanish section ends; El Clamor Público begins |
| 1864 | The paper is suspended after its editor's arrest |
| May 1868 | Publication resumes |
| June 1, 1870 | A daily edition begins |
| 1873 | The Los Angeles Daily Herald begins |
| 1879 | The sheriff attaches the paper for debt and it closes |
| December 4, 1881 | The Los Angeles Daily Times begins |
The sequence shows how thin the margin was for a paper in a small city. The Star lasted nearly three decades, but it was suspended once, changed its language policy once and ended in a debt case. Its successors did better partly because the city they served was far larger.
What the Star left behind
The paper's most important legacy is the record it created. For historians, the Star is a primary source for the city between statehood and the boom, with details on land sales, local government, the lives of ranchers and merchants, and the politics of the Civil War. Libraries and archives hold the paper in bound volumes and in digital and microfilm collections, so researchers and curious residents can read the pages that Angelenos read in the 1850s and 1860s. The Los Angeles Public Library, whose history is told in The County Library of 1912 and the growth of public libraries and The Los Angeles Public Library: the Central Library and 73 locations, is one place to start, as are the city's archives.
The Star also set a pattern. Los Angeles has always been a city of many media: bilingual papers in the nineteenth century, a daily paper that grew into an empire, a strong ethnic press and later a radio and television industry. Writing the city: books and authors of Los Angeles looks at how authors have portrayed the city, and the books they wrote often drew on the newspapers' record of local life.
How to explore it today
A few ways to bring the history to life:
- Walk the Plaza. The old pueblo center is still there at El Pueblo, where the Avila Adobe stands; El Pueblo de Los Angeles and the Avila Adobe, built in 1818 describes the district.
- Read a page. Digital newspaper archives let anyone search the papers of the period. A search for a street or a family name often turns up advertisements and notices from the 1850s and 1870s.
- Visit the library. The Central Library and its history collections hold local newspapers, maps and photographs. Downtown Los Angeles describes the part of the city where much of this history happened.
- Compare then and now. Lay an 1851 issue's two-language layout beside a modern bilingual newspaper or website and the continuity is clear: Los Angeles is still a city where two or more languages share a page.
The lesson of a four-page paper
The first issue of the Star was small, but it contained a whole theory of the city. A place that begins with a bilingual paper expects to include more than one community, and the later history of Los Angeles, with its waves of immigration and its many languages, bears that out. A paper that survives on legal notices and advertising depends on the public's need for information and the merchants' need for customers, which has been true of local news ever since. And a paper that stops because its editor was arrested or its debts came due is a reminder that the institutions that tell a city's story are fragile. The Star had twenty-eight years. What it printed is still being read.