Blog

The 1859 vote to split southern California off as a new territory called Colorado

In 1859 Los Angeles County voted 1,407 to 441 to break from California as a territory named Colorado; the Pico Act went to Washington and never came to a vote.

Picture a few hundred men in a small adobe town in 1859, walking to a polling place to answer a question that sounds impossible now: should the south break away from California and become a federal territory of its own? Nine years after statehood, voters in the southern part of it said yes, by a wide margin. In Los Angeles County the vote was 1,407 in favor and 441 against. The new territory was to be called Colorado, a name taken from the river on its eastern edge, not from the Rocky Mountain territory that would take the same name two years later. The plan went to Washington, and then the country had bigger things to worry about. This is the story of a political proposal that came close to changing the map of California and ended up a footnote.

The state that was just a decade old

California entered the Union in September 1850, five months after Los Angeles was incorporated as a city on April 4, 1850. The state's population and its politics were concentrated in the north. The Gold Rush had filled San Francisco, Sacramento and the mining towns of the Sierra foothills, and the state government met in the north. Los Angeles, by contrast, was a small pueblo, founded in 1781, still home to many Spanish-speaking families whose land grants dated from the Mexican period, and still centered on cattle ranching.

Several grievances fed the sense that southern California had interests different from those of the rest of the state. Landowners in the south complained about taxes and about a government that seemed far away. The region's population was small, so its representation in Sacramento was small as well. Some of the feeling also traced to the politics of the era: Californians in the southern counties included many who were sympathetic to Southern positions in the national debate over slavery, which tangled the question of a separate territory with the largest national argument. The state constitution of 1849 had banned slavery, and the idea of a territory in the south raised the possibility, in some minds, of reopening the question. Historians have disagreed about how much weight to give that national question compared with the local grievances over taxes and distance.

Earlier attempts to divide the state had already come up. Southern leaders had floated the idea during the state's first years, and the notion of splitting California was familiar by 1859.

The Pico Act

The 1859 proposal is known as the Pico Act, after Andrés Pico, a leading Californio figure from Los Angeles who introduced it in the state legislature. Pico had been a military officer in the Mexican period and was now a prominent landowner and a state legislator. His bill proposed splitting off the southern counties as a separate federal territory.

The bill passed the California Legislature and was signed by Governor John B. Weller. It provided that the question be put to the voters of the affected counties, and that if they approved, the matter would go to Congress. The proposed boundary would have run east from the northwest corner of San Luis Obispo County, then northeast to the Nevada line, cutting through Tulare County. The new territory would have been named Colorado.

That last detail has caused some confusion, because a different Colorado Territory was created in 1861, in the Rocky Mountains. The 1859 proposal was about a territory in what is now southern California, named for the Colorado River. The two have no connection, other than the coincidence of the name.

The vote

The election on the question was held in 1859 in the counties that would be part of the new territory. The result was lopsided. Across the southern counties the tally was 2,447 in favor and 828 against, which is about 74.7 percent for and 25.3 percent against, out of 3,275 votes cast. In Los Angeles County, the largest of the counties, the vote was 1,407 to 441, close to three to one.

A few things are worth saying about those numbers:

  • They are small. Fewer than 2,000 people voted in Los Angeles County. In 1859 the right to vote was limited to adult male citizens, and many of the residents of the pueblo and the county, including women, Native people, and Chinese immigrants, could not take part.
  • The margin is large. A three-to-one result is a strong signal of local feeling, whatever its causes.
  • It was a question to Congress. The vote did not itself create a territory. It authorized the state's request to Washington, where the decision would be made.

The sequence of events

Date What happened
September 4, 1781 The pueblo of Los Angeles is founded
1849 California's constitutional convention meets
February 1850 Los Angeles County is created as one of the original counties
April 4, 1850 Los Angeles is incorporated as a city
September 1850 California becomes a state
1851 The Los Angeles Star begins publication
1852 The state Legislature creates the county Board of Supervisors
1859 The Pico Act passes the Legislature and is signed by the governor; southern voters approve it
November 1860 Abraham Lincoln is elected and the secession crisis begins
1861 The Civil War begins and Congress does not act on the proposal

Laid out this way, the timing is the story. The proposal was voted on in the last full year of calm before the national crisis, and it fell into the gap between the two.

What happened in Washington

Once voters approved, the Pico Act was sent to Washington. Milton Latham, who was governor at the start of 1860 and then a United States senator, continued to push the proposal in the capital. It never came to a vote in Congress.

The reason was the national crisis. Abraham Lincoln was elected president in November 1860, and the secession of Southern states followed. Congress was consumed with the question of whether the Union would hold together, and creating a new territory in the Southwest was not a priority. Whatever the merits of the proposal, it arrived at a time when the nation was breaking apart.

It is sometimes said that Congress rejected the plan. The record is more modest: Congress did not take it up, and the proposal died through inaction as the Civil War began. That is a different kind of end from a vote against it, and it leaves open the question of what might have happened if the country had been calmer.

Why the idea faded

By the time the Civil War ended in 1865, the circumstances had changed. California had stayed in the Union, and its economy was growing. In the following decades, Southern California's population grew dramatically as railroads arrived and boosters promoted the climate. The 1880s brought a land boom, the 1890s brought oil, and the region's ties to the rest of the state strengthened. As Los Angeles grew, it moved from being a small southern outpost to being a major force in the state. Los Angeles by the numbers, 1820 to 2025 charts that growth.

The pueblo that Pico knew was still visible in the city's older streets, and the founding is covered in The founding of the pueblo on September 4, 1781; the city's first newspapers, which reported on public life in these years, are in The Los Angeles Star and the city's first newspapers. The city's incorporation date is the subject of April 4, 1850: Los Angeles becomes an American city.

Why it is worth remembering

The 1859 vote is a reminder of how provisional the map was. California had been a state for less than ten years, its boundaries had been set by the 1849 constitutional convention and the idea that it would stay a single political unit was still an open question. The people of Los Angeles County had a chance to say they would rather belong to something else, and they said so loudly.

It also helps explain a part of the county's government. Los Angeles County was created in 1850 as one of the state's original counties, and it has long been a unit of local government with its own elected officials and independent powers, a topic covered in City or county? Who does what in Los Angeles government and Los Angeles County government. The five-member Board of Supervisors, created by the state Legislature in 1852, governs it, and The county Board of Supervisors since 1852 tells that story. The county was a political unit before the city was big, and it has had its own interests ever since.

Finally, the story is a useful corrective to the idea that proposals to divide California are a modern invention. The idea has resurfaced from time to time since, in different forms, and the pattern is old: a large, diverse state with several regional centers of population produces periodic arguments that one part should be separate from another. The 1859 version had a name, a boundary line and a vote, and it came closer to Congress than most.

Reading the story fairly

It is easy to tell this as a joke about a secession that never happened, or as a lost opportunity, and neither captures what the record shows. The vote was real and the margin was wide. The proposal was a legitimate act of the state government, passed by the Legislature and signed by the governor, and it was presented to Congress in the ordinary way. It was not a rebellion. What it reflected was a feeling, among a small electorate in a distant region, that its needs were different from those of the rest of the state, and a belief that a separate territory would give it more control over its taxes and its land. Whether that belief was right is a question historians can argue about, and the proposal ended before anyone could test it.

The episode also shows how different the electorate of 1859 was from today's. Its voters were fewer than two thousand men in Los Angeles County, and the decision would have affected the lives of many people who had no vote. Compare the county's 1859 vote total of 1,848 with the 2026 city election, when more than 800,000 ballots were counted in the mayor's runoff alone, and the growth of the community is plain.

Where to read more

The text of the Pico Act and the legislative record are public documents, held in the state's archives. The local history collections at the Los Angeles Public Library and the City Archives have material on the period, and The Los Angeles Public Library: the Central Library and 73 locations describes the library's holdings. For a visual sense of the city that voted, a visit to the Plaza and the Avila Adobe, covered in El Pueblo de Los Angeles and the Avila Adobe, built in 1818, shows the scale of the town in the 1850s.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic