Blog

Owens Valley and the water wars: the case against and for the aqueduct

Los Angeles built a 215-mile aqueduct to the Owens Valley in 1913. What the farmers, the city and the dust on a dry lakebed each say, and what the record shows.

Late on the night of November 16, 1924, a band of Owens Valley men led by Mark Watterson took over the Alabama Gates, a spillway on the Los Angeles Aqueduct about 200 miles north of the city, and opened them. Water bound for Los Angeles ran back toward the valley floor. The seizure lasted days and ended without a fight, but it was the high point of a quarrel that has never quite ended: over a river, a lake, a city's growth and what a region owes the place it draws water from.

What follows is a case in the old sense, a dispute laid out from the public record with each side's argument given fairly. It covers what Los Angeles did, why, what it cost the Owens Valley, and the unusual way the city now pays for it.

The city's problem

By the early 1900s Los Angeles was growing faster than its river could support. The city had come a long way from a Spanish pueblo founded September 4, 1781, and its leaders feared that the local water supply would put a ceiling on the future. Their answer was to look elsewhere. Fred Eaton, a former mayor, and William Mulholland, the head of the city's water department, settled on the Owens River, which runs down the east side of the Sierra Nevada some 230 miles away.

Voters approved bond money for land purchases and construction in the first decade of the century, and the city began to build. The Los Angeles Aqueduct, put up by the city's own workers over about five years, was completed in 1913, with 215 miles of conduit and a string of reservoirs, and it carried water by gravity from the Owens Valley to the San Fernando Valley and the city. The opening is remembered for a line attributed to Mulholland as the water arrived: "There it is. Take it." The aqueduct let the city grow far past the limits of its local supply, and it remains a core piece of the municipal utility run by the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, described in Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and in The Los Angeles Aqueduct of 1913: how a city reached for distant water.

The valley's case

The Owens Valley's complaint starts with how the water was acquired. Critics said city agents bought farmland and water rights through intermediaries, without telling sellers that the buyer was Los Angeles, which kept prices low. The farmers then watched the water that had irrigated their orchards and fields head for a distant city. As the city bought more land, irrigated farming shrank, and towns that had counted on a growing agricultural economy declined.

The conflict turned physical. Farmers and residents dynamited the aqueduct several times in the 1920s, and the 1924 occupation of the Alabama Gates was the best-known protest. The city answered with armed guards and lawsuits, and the valley's economic base weakened. By 1926 Owens Lake, at the bottom of the valley, was completely dry, its inflow diverted. The lakebed has never returned to its natural condition.

Those who make the case against the aqueduct have several points:

  • The water was taken from a place that did not benefit. The valley saw little economic return from a diversion that built a city hundreds of miles away.
  • The method of purchase was unfair. Land was bought through agents who hid the identity of the buyer.
  • The environmental cost lasted generations. A lake that once supported birds and a local economy became a source of dust.
  • Later extensions repeated the pattern. The aqueduct was extended into the Mono Basin in the early 1940s, which set off a separate fight over Mono Lake and eventually a 1994 state decision that limited the city's diversions to protect the lake.

The city's case

Defenders of the aqueduct, then and now, argue differently, and the argument deserves a fair hearing.

  • The city needed water to exist as a large city. Without imported water, Los Angeles could not have supported the population it reached. Voters approved the aqueduct through bond measures, and a public agency carried it out, not a private company.
  • The purchases were legal. The city bought land and water rights from willing sellers, and its legal right to the water has been upheld in court. Those who sold were paid. Defenders point out that land-buying agents often keep a buyer's identity private in any market.
  • The aqueduct was a public project built with public money. It was a major piece of engineering, finished on schedule by municipal crews, and it has supplied the city's residents for more than a century.
  • The city has changed its practices. Over recent decades it has reduced its diversions, paid for environmental work in the valley and accepted limits on how much it takes.

The argument goes on in part because both sets of facts are true. The aqueduct was a lawful, voter-approved public project that made modern Los Angeles possible, and it also took water from a community that had not agreed to give it up and left lasting harm.

The dust

The most visible legacy of the water wars is the Owens Lake bed itself. When the lake dried, it left a vast flat of fine mineral dust. Wind lifts it, and the resulting particulate pollution became one of the largest sources of dust in the nation. The regional air agency, the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District, has required the city to control that dust, since the pollution follows from the city's diversion.

For decades the city and the district disputed how. In December 2014 the Sacramento Superior Court approved a stipulated judgment between the Department of Water and Power and the air district that settled the main lawsuits and set the rules for dust control. Under that agreement the city has controlled dust across tens of square miles of lakebed. Phase 9/10 of the work, due by the end of 2017, brought the total to 48.6 square miles of controlled area, with another 4.8 square miles that could be ordered within a maximum area, for a possible total of about 53.4 square miles.

The methods matter, because they use water, the very resource in dispute. The main technique is shallow flooding, a thin layer of water laid over the lakebed to keep the dust down, and it accounts for about 60 percent of the controls. The judgment encourages methods that use less water or none, such as gravel, managed vegetation and other measures, and it created a scientific advisory panel to evaluate alternatives. A 2020 report by the National Academies found that none of the measures had yet been documented to meet the required dust control while also using substantially less water. The Department of Water and Power says it has reduced dust emissions from the lake by about 99.4 percent, a figure the district does not necessarily accept, and the two agencies have gone on differing over enforcement and cost.

What it means for Los Angeles now

Los Angeles does not live on the aqueduct alone. The city draws water from several sources: the Los Angeles Aqueduct, imported supply purchased through the regional wholesale agency, local groundwater and recycled water. The share from each shifts from year to year with snowpack and drought. The story of those sources is told in Where Los Angeles gets its water: the aqueduct and LADWP today. A customer who wants to follow how those costs reach a bill can start with Your DWP bill: water and power, what appears on it and how to start service.

The Department of Water and Power also carries the dust-control work, and its costs are part of the utility's overall spending. The city's role in water infrastructure includes projects overseen by the Department of Public Works, described in Department of Public Works. The other great water-engineering story of the period, the failure of the St. Francis Dam in 1928, is told in The St. Francis Dam failure of March 12, 1928.

Weather and seasons matter to the supply. A wet winter in the Sierra Nevada fills the aqueduct, and a dry one thins it. For the rhythms of Southern California's own wet and dry seasons, Los Angeles seasons and what to pack is a good place to start.

A timeline of the dispute

  • 1913. The first Los Angeles Aqueduct opens, with 215 miles of conduit.
  • 1924. On November 16, armed Owens Valley residents take over the Alabama Gates and open the spillway.
  • 1920s. Farmers dynamite sections of the aqueduct on several occasions.
  • 1926. Owens Lake, deprived of its inflow, is completely dry.
  • Early 1940s. The aqueduct is extended to the Mono Basin, and a new conflict begins there.
  • 1994. A state decision restricts diversions from the Mono Basin to protect Mono Lake.
  • December 30, 2014. The stipulated judgment on Owens Lake dust control is approved.
  • 2017. Phase 9/10 of the dust-control work is due, bringing the controlled lakebed to 48.6 square miles.

Questions people ask

Does Los Angeles still take water from the Owens Valley? Yes. The aqueduct still carries water south, though the amount varies by year and the city's overall supply comes from several sources.

Is the lake dry? The lakebed is largely dry, with controlled areas managed under the court judgment. The lake has not refilled to its natural condition.

Who pays for the dust control? The Department of Water and Power carries out and funds the work, and its costs are part of the utility's budget and rates. How a customer's bill is built is explained in Your DWP bill: water and power, what appears on it and how to start service.

Who regulates it? The Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District regulates dust in the Owens Valley, and the 2014 judgment sets out how the district and the department work together.

Reading the dispute fairly

Three plain statements sum up what the record supports:

  1. Los Angeles built a legal, voter-supported aqueduct that delivered water to the city beginning in 1913.
  2. The diversion dried Owens Lake by 1926, harmed the valley's agriculture and left a lasting dust problem.
  3. The city is now bound by a court judgment to control that dust across a large area and to look for ways to do it with less water.

Drive north on U.S. 395 and the Owens Valley opens out, the lakebed flat and pale below the Sierra Nevada. The dust-control areas show from the highway as level sections, irrigated or graveled. The view holds both what the aqueduct built and what it cost.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic