Blog
Food halls versus markets, how Los Angeles eats under one roof
Covered food halls and open-air farmers markets both gather many cooks in one place, but run on different rules, schedules and economics. How they compare.
A city of big distances and mild weather ends up with two ways of putting food in one place. One is the covered market hall, a building of stalls and counters that opens every day. The other is the open-air market, a set of tents or tables that shows up on a street or in a lot for a few hours each week. Los Angeles has both in quantity, and to a visitor with a bag in each hand they look alike. In practice they run on different rules, serve different needs and have different histories, and the difference says a lot about how the city eats.
What follows compares the two models through two long-standing examples: the market hall in Downtown that opened in 1917 and the market at Fairfax and Third that opened in 1934.
Two kinds of "under one roof"
A food hall is a building, or part of one, leased to many small food businesses that share seating and common areas. The owner of each stall is separate; the landlord or operator runs the building, the lease terms and the common spaces. Some halls sell fresh ingredients as well, like produce, meat and fish. Others focus on prepared food, and many mix the two.
A farmers market in California has a narrower legal definition. A certified farmers' market is a market where farmers sell the products they grow themselves. The program is overseen by the state, and the county agricultural commissioner certifies both the market and the growers. The point of the system is to guarantee that the person behind the table is the one who grew the fruit. Many markets also allow prepared-food vendors, crafts and other stalls, but the produce rules set the character.
The two models can overlap. A market hall can host a farmers' stall, and a weekly farmers' market can have a lunch row bigger than some food halls. The differences come down to time, permanence and rules.
The Downtown hall
The oldest covered food market in the city center is the one on Broadway in Downtown Los Angeles, which opened in 1917. It occupies the ground floor of an older building and has served the area through every phase of the district's history: the years when Broadway was the main shopping street, the decades when Downtown emptied out and the recent revival of the Historic Core. Its stalls have historically sold produce, meat, spices and prepared food, reflecting the immigrant communities who shopped there. The hall's long life is partly a matter of location, one block from the old theaters and the Bunker Hill funicular, and partly a matter of adaptation, since it has changed its vendors repeatedly.
For visitors, it is one stop on the Downtown walk in Downtown's Historic Core, a walk from Pershing Square to Spring Street and a reminder of what the neighborhood was. For residents, it remains a place to buy groceries, a lunch counter and a meeting spot all at once. The Downtown Los Angeles page gives the broader context.
The market at Fairfax and Third
The other landmark opened in 1934 at Fairfax Avenue and Third Street, in what is now the Fairfax District and the Mid-Wilshire area. It began as a cluster of farmers selling from their trucks and grew into a permanent market of stalls and counters under an iconic clock tower. It has a long record as a gathering place for locals and visitors, and it anchors the district around it. A larger outdoor shopping center that opened later sits next door.
The model there is a hybrid. The market has year-round stalls with fixed businesses, a mix of grocers, butchers, bakers and prepared-food counters, and a shared seating area where visitors can buy from different stalls and eat together. It is a food hall in the modern sense, but older than the term, and it is described in Fairfax District and the blog's The Fairfax District: a neighborhood walk along Fairfax Avenue piece.
The street markets
The city's open-air markets are different in kind. Many are weekly: a Saturday morning market in one neighborhood, a Sunday one in another, a midweek one in a parking lot or beside a school. The Los Angeles farmers market year, season by season covers what is on the tables in each season, and the pattern is basic. Winter brings citrus and greens. Spring brings strawberries and the first stone fruit. Summer is the peak of tomatoes, melons and peaches. Fall brings apples, persimmons and pomegranates. Because the climate allows year-round growing in much of the region, there is rarely a month with nothing to sell.
What makes an outdoor market work is a permit and a closed street. A market operator needs an agreement with the city or the property owner to use the space, and for street closures needs the transportation department to approve them. The city's transportation department, covered in Los Angeles Department of Transportation, handles street-use permits. On market day the street changes function, and the neighbors adjust.
How they compare
| Factor | Food hall | Farmers market |
|---|---|---|
| Hours | Open daily, fixed hours | A few hours, one or a few days a week |
| Weather | Indoors or covered | Outdoors, affected by heat and rain |
| Who sells | Tenants with leases | Growers, plus other vendors |
| What you can buy | Prepared food, often groceries | Produce first, prepared food second |
| Costs to a vendor | Rent, build-out | Stall fee, travel, setup each time |
| Rules | Health permits, lease terms | Certification, health permits |
| Seating | Shared tables, usually | Usually little or none |
For a vendor, the hall is a bet on rent and the market is a bet on weather and travel. A hall offers a fixed location and a steady stream of foot traffic but requires a lease and build-out; a market offers a low-barrier way to test a product, because a vendor with a table and a permit can start. For a shopper, the hall is better when you want something now, while the market is better when you want to see what is in season and talk to the grower.
Health and safety
Prepared food is regulated at the county level, not the city's. Los Angeles County's public health department inspects food facilities, issues the letter grades displayed in restaurant windows and permits vendors at markets. A stall in a food hall is generally inspected as its own food facility, and a prepared-food vendor at a farmers' market needs a health permit. The grading card system is explained in Reading a Los Angeles restaurant grade card. Fresh produce, meanwhile, falls under the certified farmers' market rules and state food safety standards.
Food trucks belong to the same ecosystem, and they follow their own rules; see Food trucks in Los Angeles: what the county inspects and where trucks can park. A truck at a market is a vendor like any other, and its permits come from the county.
Why the city has both
The deeper answer is geography. Los Angeles is spread across a vast area, with neighborhoods that each want their own center. A single central market could never serve all of them, and a hundred permanent halls could not be supported by the foot traffic of a city built around cars. The weekly market solves that by moving the food to the neighbors: a few hours in a lot, then gone. The hall solves a different problem, the need for an everyday place in a dense district where people want lunch.
The two also serve different communities. Halls in the city center and in dense commercial districts tend to draw office workers and visitors, while neighborhood markets draw residents who go every week and know the farmers by name. Both are places where immigrant food traditions, from Mexican produce stalls to Armenian bakeries to Korean grocers, meet customers who might never visit the original restaurant.
A sample Saturday
A hypothetical shows how the two models can work together. Say a household plans a Saturday around food. In the morning they walk a neighborhood farmers market for fruit and vegetables, buying what the growers have that week, and stop at a prepared-food stall for breakfast. At midday they take transit to a food hall, where each person at the table can order from a different counter, which is the hall's real strength: a group that cannot agree on one restaurant can still sit together. In the afternoon they buy bread, cheese or fish from a hall's grocery stalls to carry home.
The produce came from the market, the meal came from the hall and the groceries came from both, and the household spent the day moving between two systems that share one purpose. Neither would be a complete answer alone. A market without a hall disappears at noon, and a hall without a market has a hard time offering what is fresh this week.
That complementarity is why planners and neighborhood groups often want both. A district that has a weekly market but no permanent place to eat nearby loses its visitors at lunchtime, and a district with a hall but no market has fewer reasons for residents to come every week. Cities that want lively street life tend to cultivate both, and Los Angeles, with a half-dozen older halls and a market on nearly every day of the week, has grown into the arrangement more or less by accident.
Using them well
A few suggestions for a first visit to each:
- Go early to a farmers market. The best produce goes first, and mornings are cooler. Bring bags.
- Walk the whole market before buying. Prices and quality vary, and a lap tells you where to start.
- Go off-peak to a hall. Weekday mornings and mid-afternoons are quiet; lunch hour and weekends are crowded.
- Check the parking. Neighborhood markets often take over streets, and a hall's parking may be validated or paid. A transit ride or a bike can be simpler.
- Look at the grade card. For any food vendor, the county's letter grade is a quick signal.
The free options are in Free things to do in Los Angeles, and a walk through either a hall or a market costs nothing but the food you decide to buy. The market hall and the weekly stall are two answers to the same question: how can a city of millions buy lunch from the people who made it?
Los Angeles County's Department of Public Health lists the grades and inspection results for food facilities.