Blog
City Hall scandals and the reform push: what the public record shows
Corruption cases and a 2022 leaked recording led to a charter reform commission and six 2026 amendments. What each side argues and what the package leaves out.
Every city has a bad stretch now and then. Few have had one as public as the years from 2020 to 2023 at Los Angeles City Hall. Federal prosecutors charged members of the City Council with corruption. A leaked audio recording of a private conversation among council members exposed racist remarks and a discussion of how to draw political districts. The council president resigned. Newspapers and commentators told voters something in the way the city governs itself was broken, and the city's answer became a package of changes to its founding document, six of which went to voters on November 3, 2026. What follows sets out the public record, what the reformers proposed, what the council actually put forward and where the arguments run, without taking a side.
The cases
In the years before the 2022 recording, federal prosecutors brought cases involving members of the council and their staff. By mid-2023, according to the news organization LAist's review, one former councilmember had been convicted on federal bribery and corruption charges and another had pleaded guilty to federal racketeering and tax evasion charges. The same account notes that a sitting councilmember had been indicted on embezzlement and perjury charges, which are accusations; the courts decide such cases.
These were not the first corruption cases in the city's history, and press coverage at the time called them "yet another" scandal. They are a matter of court records, and the facts of each case live in the charging documents and verdicts, not in a summary like this one. What matters for the reform discussion is the pattern observers drew from them: a council in which each member held a large amount of control over development decisions in a district, with little outside check.
The 2022 recording
In October 2022, audio of a meeting held a year earlier was published. In it, three members of the council and a labor leader discussed the redrawing of council district boundaries, and some of the remarks were racist and derogatory toward other residents and colleagues. The council president at the time was one of the speakers and resigned. Of the three council members on the recording, according to a one-year review by LAist, one resigned, one lost his seat at the next election, and the third was censured by the council and removed from his committee assignments. Seven of the fifteen seats changed hands in the following year, six by election and one by appointment, and the council moved toward the more progressive end of the spectrum, with renter protections passing unanimously.
The scandal was not only about the language. The conversation concerned redistricting, the process by which the council redraws its fifteen districts after each census, and it suggested that members were weighing how the lines would affect their own prospects and those of their colleagues. The state attorney general announced an independent investigation into whether the process violated the state Voting Rights Act, and the redistricting map the council approved at that time changed one council member's district by about 40 percent. Redistricting is covered in Fifteen districts, one map: how Los Angeles draws its council boundaries.
What reformers proposed
The scandal opened an argument about how Los Angeles governs itself, and the proposals that came out of it reached beyond ethics. Reform advocates, including a group formed in 2022 that called itself the Reform Project, argued for three changes:
- A larger council. Expand from 15 seats to 25, so each member represents fewer people. In a city of nearly 3.9 million, each of the 15 districts holds about a quarter of a million residents, a figure reformers called too large for personal representation.
- Independent redistricting. Replace the council's final say over district lines with an independent commission, a model the state has used for its own legislative districts.
- Stronger ethics oversight. Give the Ethics Commission broader preventive powers, extending from rules and regulations to the city's ordinances.
Scholars quoted in the press at the time said public appetite for reform was growing. One described residents calling their council districts "fiefdoms," and another said there was broad agreement that redistricting should be taken out of the council's hands. Changing the charter requires a citywide vote, and a ballot date in November 2024 was discussed.
What the council did
The council did not simply adopt the reformers' list. Its president created an ad hoc committee on governance reform in December 2022, which advanced a proposal for an independent redistricting commission and considered expanding the council. The full council then had to decide whether to put changes on the ballot. Press accounts later reported that the council moved to place a package of ethics reforms before voters but dropped several key proposals along the way, and critics said the reforms would not be enough.
The mayor and the council created a Charter Reform Commission to study the charter and make recommendations, and the six charter amendments on the November 2026 ballot are the product of that process. They are:
| Measure | What it does, per the public voter guide |
|---|---|
| EE | Cuts council meetings from three a week to at least weekly; raises the maximum fine for campaign finance violations from $2,000 to $15,000; bars ethics commissioners from running for certain offices for five years after their terms; raises the signature threshold for a referendum from 10 to 15 percent; protects the police Inspector General and the fire Independent Assessor from interference by their commissions |
| LA | Moves the city to a two-year budget; lets the council eliminate or change the Board of Public Works; gives the Public Works director more power |
| PL | Merges the seven Area Planning Commissions into one Neighborhood Appeals Commission |
| PRK | Doubles the minimum budget of Recreation and Parks over ten years |
| PRT | Adds neighbors of LAX and Van Nuys Airport to the airport commission and tightens lease rules for the Airports, Water and Power, and Harbor departments |
| SC | Removes duplicate campaign finance language for school board races |
According to unofficial results reported shortly after the election, all six passed, along with two tax measures, but the results are not final until certified. The full package is covered in The eight Los Angeles city measures on the November 3, 2026 ballot, one by one, the ethics pieces in The Ethics Commission and Los Angeles campaign finance rules and the budget change in What a two-year budget cycle would change at Los Angeles City Hall.
What the package does not include
Notice what is missing. Going by the voter guide's descriptions, none of the six amendments expands the council beyond fifteen seats or creates an independent redistricting commission, the two ideas most closely tied to the scandal's early aftermath. The amendments are, in the words of one council member quoted by LAist, "administrative" more than "ideological," and the same guide notes there was little organized opposition.
That absence is part of the argument. Supporters of the package say it makes incremental, well-defined improvements voters can evaluate, and that more sweeping changes such as a bigger council deserve a separate debate because they are costly and change the nature of representation. Critics say the package leaves the structural problems alone. One council member who opposed EE argued that fewer meetings would let "important decisions to be shaped outside the public eye," and others have said its ethics provisions have little force. Defenders respond that a higher fine and a bar on commissioners' political careers are concrete steps, and that the number of meetings is a question of workload, as explained in Why the Los Angeles City Council meets three times a week, and what Amendment EE would change.
The strongest counterarguments, stated fairly
Each side has a serious case.
For larger structural change. Fifteen members for a city this size is a low ratio compared with other large American cities, and the argument is that a larger council would be more responsive and less dependent on a single member's judgment. Independent redistricting removes a clear conflict of interest, since the people drawing the lines are the ones the lines will help or hurt.
For incremental change. A larger council costs more, adds more members to coordinate, and may make some decisions slower. Reformers who prefer smaller steps argue that the council has already changed in membership, and that the major prosecutions show it was the justice system, not the charter, that found the corruption. They say the amendments before voters fix specific problems without risking unintended consequences.
On what the evidence shows. Neither charter changes nor ethics rules can by themselves stop criminal conduct. What they can do is change incentives and raise the price of violations, and whether they do so is a question only years of experience will answer.
How to follow what comes next
A reader who wants to follow the reforms has several routes. The City Clerk's records show council votes and files, and the clerk's site lists the agendas for every meeting; see Office of the City Clerk. The Ethics Commission publishes campaign finance data and enforcement actions, described in Los Angeles City Ethics Commission. The council's own work is covered in Los Angeles City Council. And residents can speak at meetings, a process explained in Attending or watching a City Council meeting.
The city's current charter dates from 1999, and how it came to be, including the creation of neighborhood councils, is told in The 1999 City Charter: neighborhood councils, a mayor-council structure and what voters changed. The reforms now being enacted are the largest changes to it in decades, and how well they work will show in the next round of elections.
Primary documents are easy to reach. The City Clerk posts agendas, council files and votes, and the Ethics Commission publishes its enforcement actions and campaign finance data. A reader who wants to check a claim about a vote or a fine, including any above, can find the original there.